I recently discovered gracewithabookinherface on YouTube and I was inspired by one of her videos which was a historical fiction tag. It's been a while since I did a tag so I thought why not make it a book-themed one? Even though I have been reading less of it lately, historical fiction is definitely the genre I own the most of (though not necessarily the genre I have read the most of because frankly I have a lot of unread books). They're arranged chronologically on my shelves from Eleanor of Aquitaine to the post-WWII period covering pretty much everything in between so I figured I might have some interesting answers.
Why do you like to read historical fiction?
The main reason I like to read historical fiction is the educational aspect, as you can learn a huge amount about historical events and how people lived in the past just through the context. I also find that details and broader attitudes tend to stick in my mind more when I absorb them through a story with engaging characters and places rather than just reading the facts for example in a more traditional education setting. I especially love historical fiction that's written from the perspective of more disadvantaged groups including women and more specifically working class women, as I think it's only by reading about the (albeit fictionalised) experiences of those worse off that you come to build up a picture of the broader social system of the time.
What was the first historical fiction book you read?
The first book I remember reading was Bloody Tower: The Diary of Tilly Middleton, London 1553-1559. I distinctly remember getting this out of the library in primary school, so I must have been about 8 or 9 at the time, although I reckon I've read it at least three times since then. It's part of the 'My Story' series, and I can absolutely credit my love for historical fiction later in life to reading this series at a young age. I remember I had a box set of ten or so of these books including Bloody Tower, but some of my favourites were the ones set on the Titanic, in Manchester during the Industrial Revolution, and during the Irish famine. I have several of the old editions which were made to look like real diaries which just added to the authentic character of the stories. As they were written from the point of view of girls my age (or slightly older), they held my attention and utterly drew me into the stories and have really stuck with me years later. When I think of the Great Plague for instance, most of my knowledge comes not from learning about it in school or through the internet but from reading the story of 'Alice Paynton'.
Where do you draw the line for “historical fiction” and contemporary?
I tend to think of anything written recently but set pre-1900s as by definition historical fiction. Anything from 1900-1950 - which obviously covers World War Two - is kind of a grey area for me, but I also take into account the subject matter of the book when classifying something as historical fiction. For instance, if the book just happens to be set in the past, that doesn't automatically make it historical fiction - which is the case for Perfume: The Story of a Murderer by Patrick Suskind, which is set in 18th century France, for example. Also, if the main plot actually relates to key historical events of the time or features fictionalised versions of real historical figures then I'm more likely to classify it as historical fiction.
Have you read a book set in each of these eras? Stack your favorites!
1600’s or before
The earliest historical fiction novel I've read is set in 1137 and I have nearly a metre and a half's worth of shelf between then and 1600 so I have plenty to choose from! Some of my favourites from that era are by Philippa Gregory, so I'm going to say the first of her Plantagenet and Tudor series I ever read, The Other Boleyn Girl, which actually comes ninth in the chronological order of the books.
1700’s
I have relatively little set in the 1700s so I'm going to go with a trusty 'My Story': Transported: The Diary of Elizabeth Harvey, Australia, 1790.
1800’s
The 1800s are a strange time for historical fiction in my opinion because there are also so many contemporary novels from this period (think Dickens and the Brontes, for instance) which compete with our interest so it can seem oddly inauthentic to read historical fiction from this time - after all, why wouldn't we read the real thing? I'm not saying I necessarily agree with that, though. Anyway, my pick for this century is The Rose of Sebastopol by Katharine McMahon, set in the Crimean War.
1920s-30s
(For some reason this tag skips out a couple of decades but OK.) The 1920s are one of my favourite eras for fashion and all round glamour, so I'm going with a full-on flapper trilogy: Bright Young Things, Beautiful Days and The Lucky Ones by Anna Godbersen. This series is kind of a cross between 'chick flick' and historical fiction as it's highly glamourised and I would say aimed at a younger female audience, but I remember enjoying it immensely. An honourable mention goes to The Paying Guests by Sarah Waters, which is set in 1922 and is about a middle class but relatively impoverished family who are obliged to take in a lodger. It's also the first overtly LGBT fiction I ever read.
1940’s-50’s
There are so many good historical fiction novels from this period, some of which I've spoken about before. My top three would have to be Out of the Easy by Ruta Sepetys, Code Name Verity by Elizabeth Wien (which Grace also mentioned I believe) and The Amber Shadows by Lucy Ribchester. The latter I would classify as predominantly mystery but it's set in the 1940s in Bletchley Park so the story is hugely relevant to the intelligence activities which were carried out there during WWII.
1960’s-1970’s or later
As I said above I personally wouldn't classify this period as historical fiction but I suppose I would have to say The Girls by Emma Cline which is about the Manson girls. It's not a topic I know a lot about but I enjoyed the book.
What was the last historical fiction book you read?
The Silent Companions by Laura Purcell. Again this is arguably also mystery/horror in addition to historical, but it's the closest thing to historical fiction that I've read recently. I wrote a bit about it in my Waterstones book haul post.
What’s your favorite historical fiction cover?
I really love most of Philippa Gregory's book covers, but to mix it up a bit I'll say Gilt by Katherine Longshore. This cover is so simple but really draws you in, I think it's beautiful. This copy is also signed by the author, and I came across it completely by chance in a bookshop in Toronto with my cousin and just had to buy it.
What’s your favorite historical fiction?
I'm not sure what this question is asking exactly but Grace interpreted it as her favourite historical fiction novel so I'm going to go with the book which had the biggest impact on me, which is probably Voyage on the Great Titanic: The Diary of Margaret Ann Brady, RMS Titanic, 1912. When I read this at about age 10 it was the first time I'd heard the story of Titanic, and it really stuck with me. Unless they have a personal family story, I think when other people think about the ship they probably associate it most with the characters in the 1997 film, but for me the biggest association has always been the character of Margaret and although she isn't real it was her I thought of when I visited the Titanic museum in Belfast a couple of years ago.
Phew, that was a long one! Well done if you read it right to the end.
